Puzzle Description:

Over or under, why would I care? Just as long as the t.p. is there.

#1: Nancy Kay (joyfulnancy) on Feb 23, 2011

OVER!!

over

doesn't matter to me - great puzzle!

Over... love the puzzle.

And poetry too! .... over for me, but you can't see, that i don't use it when i pee :D

Over. Especially if you've got one of those in-the-wall tp holders -- keeps the paper from getting jammed up in it.

Totally Priceless. OVER!

LReally fun pic!!! :-) I read an article that said that men tend to put it under and women over... don't remember why though!!!
Over!!!! :-)
Thanks for giving me a big smile!!! :-)

over! great puzzle!

over...good one

Over, too! Hey, do you think we all say over because over is the logical choice? I do find it curious that so far all of us agree upon over. Do we have no undies among us?

Under is icky.

my mother (90 yr) has it in the under position

Tom, great poem. Over for me.

Under! Clever -- didn't dawn on me til the last pixel

Comment Suppressed:Click below to view hints

Under. Because when you tear the paper off, the weight of the roll offers resistance and makes it an easier one-handed operation. But, I wouldn't let a relationship hinge on it.

The most compelling argument for "under" I've heard is so it won't completely unroll when the cat starts batting at it.

Otherwise I'm an "over" person.

Over. And cdprhys, I still do my floors on my hands and knees, also. I can't stand the streaks of dirt left behind by a mop. I like skweedle's explanation of the "under" theory, but my question is "where is your other hand?" LOL

haha!

hey... at least this group uses t.p.

I can't believe all the overs - I have always been an under myself because it seems to be easier to find the end. I like the theory about the cat. Great puzzle idea Sarah

Ellen -Typing the answer to your question.
And, as far as my cats go, if they can get at it, the whole roll is gone.

great comments. lol Tom. Skweedle, only on webPBN, would science be applied to toilet paper lol(# 17). Wombat and Skweedle --so true about cats!

I agree with your initial poem Sarah, over, under, I don't care. It just peeves me when the last person who uses the roll leaves one little scrap of paper on it...this way it's technically not completely used up and therefore it doesn't need to be changed!!!

totally agree with the last part Carol.
but definitely OVER for me!

I had a cat who would unroll the entire roll if it was over so during the time of Summerset I was an under guy but after he passed out of my life I went back to over.

btw he also liked to play fetch.

kinda like the salt shaker, Carol?

Yep, or the last sip of milk, etc....

As far as the T.P. goes, OVER always! On other subjects, it depends on the mood and circumstances ... You guys are all so much fun! And this puzzle is fantastic!

Since my husband and I have been empty nesters, there are no more "empty" rolls, or milk, or salt shakers, or half a**ed shoveling, or washed dishes....etc.... We are just the happiest couple in the world! And thanks, skweedle. I like your answer!

Over! Funny poem, Tom. Ellen, I'm with you on the joys of an empty nest!

Over!! to remember it is "Roll Over"

Over here!

Under is not necessarily proof against kitties.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWQzqky2lqQ

And any paper on a roll is vulnerable.
http://cheezburger.com/625468672

I miss Sarah

Over. If you don't want your kitty to roll it out, just squeeze the tube before you put it on. Of course that makes a lumpy unroll when YOU want it, but ...

If you look at the patent for the first toilet paper holder it is drawn with the toilet paper hanging over! Regardless of what people do, the original intention is clear.

Hilarious

Show: Hints

Goto next topic

You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.