Comments on Puzzle #3356: WC #1 "splish splash
By harris harris (torough4u)
peek at solution solve puzzle
version: 2 quality: 
difficulty: 
solutions: multiple solvability: some guessing?
peek at solution solve puzzle
version: 2 quality: difficulty: solutions: multiple solvability: some guessing?
Puzzle Description:
Mermaid
#1: Kuuipo (monkeylover) on Aug 28, 2008
harris, you may need to make this smaller the size is suppose to be 40x40 or smaller#2: harris harris (torough4u) on Aug 28, 2008
:)
oppps.. ill fix#3: Jane Doe (telly) on Aug 28, 2008
nice fix. looks great! ;)#4: Sylvain "WCPman" (qwerty) on Aug 28, 2008 [SPOILER]
the Cher movie or the little one from Disney...:)#5: Kuuipo (monkeylover) on Aug 28, 2008
thanks for your participation
lol#6: harris harris (torough4u) on Aug 28, 2008
disney#7: Minnie Fuerstnau (m.fuerstnau) on Aug 29, 2008 [SPOILER]
Good job! I like how her hair is flowing in the water. Thank you for a nice puzzle.#8: Byrdie (byrdie) on Jan 2, 2011 [HINT] [SPOILER]
Comment Suppressed:Click below to view hints#9: Martha Valdés (maval) on Feb 12, 2011
This would be a nice puzzle if it had a unique solution. Multiple solutions puzzles aren't PBN puzzles.#10: Cynthia Lynn McDaniel (mcaardva) on Sep 3, 2013
Once again, I would argue that 'obvious' is also 'logical'. Nice solving puzzle!#11: Bryan (Cyclone) on Jan 5, 2014
I finally just used the solution to fill this in. I have left it untouched for a long time since first seeing it because of the guessing being required (not sure why lizzard or Jan or someone hasn't confirmed it yet). The eyes are obviously not logical. That alone makes it an invalid puzzle.
Show: Hints
You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.