Web Paint-by-Number Forum
Comments on Puzzle #29720: Trapped Inside This
By Luke Oliver (lukesome544)

peek at solution       solve puzzle
  quality:   difficulty:   solvability: moderate lookahead  

Puzzle Description:

Dream Theater's Octavarium Cover Art

#1: Web Paint-By-Number Robot (webpbn) on Apr 26, 2017

Found to be solvable with moderate lookahead by gator.
#2: Gator (gator) on Apr 26, 2017 [HINT]
All of these steps may not be required.

After the initial line/color logic, all of the blue and green will be finished and the bottom half of the puzzle mostly filled in.

If we look at the 6 clue in column 32, it looks like it can go somewhere in rows 5-17. But look at how row 8 and column 33 would be affected by this. If the 6 clue existed at R8C32, then R8C33 would be a dot which pushes the 9 clue down. Then this forces the 7 clue in R15 to make R15C32 black which would make C32 invalid. So the 6 clue cannot occupy R8C32 (but we cannot make it a dot as the 3 clue could be there). Now we see the 6 clue is restricted to rows 9 - 17. This lets us make R12-14C32 black. LL

R13C23 is either part of the 5 clue or the third 1 clue. Let's consider it to be the 5 clue for now. If it extends to C24 or C25, this will make row 14 invalid. So R13C24-25 are dots as they would also be dots if R13C23 was the 1 clue. LL

In C1, if R19, R20, or R21 is black, this will extend the 6 in column 6 up to row 17 which would force R17C1 to be black. This would make C1 invalid. So R19-21C1 are dots. LL

If either R15C1 or R21C2 is black, this will cause R17 to be invalid, so these are dots.

The 6 in C3 has to either go in R1-8 or R13-21. Let's consider it going in R1-8 and how this affects C6. R6C3 would be black forcing R6C6 to be black also. R14C3 would be a dot forcing R14C6 to be black. This makes C6 invalid, so the 6 cannot go in R1-8. Mark these as dots, and R16-18C3 as black. LL (a lot of it).

If both R14-15C16 are dots, then this will cause a contradiction in R15 as R15C13 cannot be both a dot and black. So at least one of R14-15C16 must be black make R15C16 black in both cases. LL to finish.

I feel like this one is in the middle between moderate and deep lookahead as you had to keep a lot in your head for some parts. I'm going to mark it as moderate for now.

Nice puzzle.

#3: Teresa K (fasstar) on Apr 26, 2017
Wow! Really interesting (and difficult) and rewarding solve. Fun aha! moment of recognition.

I had to look it up.
Dream Theater is the band.
Octavarium is the album.
Title is from the lyrics.

I'm not really into metal, but this stuff is great!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PUpYBAsS5Q0

#4: Aurelian Ginkgo (AurelianGinkgo) on Apr 27, 2017 [SPOILER]
I like the Newton's Cradle concept.

Goto next topic

You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.