Web Paint-by-Number Forum
Comments on Puzzle #2521: who's flag # 24
By harris harris (torough4u)

peek at solution       solve puzzle
  quality:   difficulty:   solvability: trivial  

Puzzle Description:

Czech Republic

#1: Sylvain "WCPman" (qwerty) on Mar 24, 2008

I think that we got a problem here for the quality rating on this serie. I explain myself: sure there are all easy but that suppose to be reflect on the difficulty rating. I check those flag and the real thing and its exactly what we get so why low rate on quality.

This discussion already took place in my Black on White serie but nothing change. It seem that we have to create something hudge and very complex ( nothing bad with that I done my share of them) to have great score on the quality rating and I think that not very fair for the creator of those nice but simplier puzzle

By the way nice job on that flag
#2: tjeerd oldenburger (tjeerd) on Mar 24, 2008
it is too easy
#3: Beth (Shasta) on Mar 25, 2008 [SPOILER]
I agree that you know it is easy when the difficulty rating is easy. The quality should not be reflected in the rating. I think a 3 is appropriate for this puzzle. If it had background or was blowing in the wind I would give it higher quality-but then the difficulty would be higher as well. Unless I am looking for a real quick one I look for the 3 or 4 difficulty and then get the best quality available.

Interesting that the only one I did was Czech Republic. My husbands family is Czech and I was pleased my kids recognized the flag
#4: Byrdie (byrdie) on Aug 3, 2020 [HINT] [SPOILER]
I agree with the previous comments. Difficulty is where you would reflect your opinion that this puzzle is easy. Difficulty should not be a consideration in quality. For quality the thoughts should center, as Beth discusses, around whether or not the image accurately depicts what it represents, if it's well done and if there's any thing special about the way it renders.

This flag is accurate and pretty average in its depiction. It's not poorly drawn but it also doesn't have any special characteristics to it such as an interesting logo or moving in the wind. It's average - a 3.

Goto next topic

You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.