Web Paint-by-Number Forum
Comments on Puzzle #36817: May 24 is....
By BRASH ATAOM (BRASHatAOM)

peek at solution       solve puzzle
  quality:   difficulty:   solvability: some guessing?  

Puzzle Description Suppressed:Click below to view spoilers

#1: Wombat (wombatilim) on May 12, 2023 [HINT]

Initial line & color logic solves 38%.

R5: Whether C17 or C19 is black, R6C19 will be black. L&CL (including R10C17 white, which the helper doesn’t catch).

C29: The red 1 will be in either R11 or R12. Either one will place the remaining black in C30, so R5-10 C30 are white. L&CL.

R12: One of C10-11 and one of C28-29 will be red. Each of the 2 reds will place a black in R13, so R13 C12-17 and R13 C20-27 are white. L&CL.

Stuck here for now, currently at 49%.
#2: Gator (gator) on May 13, 2023 [HINT]
Either R4C9 or R6C9 has to be black. In either case, this forces R6C8 to be black. LL. 61%
#3: David Bouldin (dbouldin) on May 15, 2023 [HINT]
don't have time to overlay my strategy with you guys to note where i pick up...or whether some of this is unnecessary. i will point out a fun dot of line logic that i (and others) would consider "gator logic" and that is

- whether the black in C12R10 is the one clue or part of the 5, C17R10 is a dot.

anyway here's my solve after initial color and LL:

- whether C29R11 or C29R12 is red, C30R5-10 are dots
- whether C9R4 or C9R6 are black, C8R6 is black
- if 11 starts in C3, R13 is violated, so C3R5 is a dot
- no matter where the 2 in C3 goes, there will always be dots in C4R4,13
- whether C4R5 or C15R5 are black, C15R6 is a dot.
- if 11 starts in C4, R11 is violated, so C4R5 is a dot.
- whether C11R10 or C16R10 is black, C11R7 is a dot :)
- the black at C12R11 has to be the black to the right of the first red by color logic. because of this the 2 clue in R11 is restricted and no matter where it goes C4R5 is a dot.
- by color logic, there will always be a black in either C10R13 or C11R13 AND C28R13 or C29R13. this dots all undotted C12-27R13.

color and LL to finish. guessing some of this is "deep" but need to run. good luck all!


#4: Wombat (wombatilim) on May 15, 2023 [HINT]
"- whether C11R10 or C16R10 is black, C11R7 is a dot :)"
This doesn't quite track. If R10C11 is black, it makes R7 C14-15 black for sure, and if R10C16 is black, it makes R7C12 black for sure. Unless you left out an intermediate step, there's no direct overlap here.

#5: Ailsa Hebert (bazette3) on May 15, 2023
Did not require any guessing. Thanks for the puzzle!
#6: Koreen (mom24plus) on May 17, 2023
an important job!
#7: Eric (kelalatir) on May 23, 2023 [HINT]
Fun puzzle! I concur that this is logically solvable. I used some advanced color logic, and some two-way logic, as well as some edge logic where available. A great mix of logic to solve this puzzle.

Show: Spoilers

Goto next topic

You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.