Puzzle Description Suppressed:Click below to view spoilers

#1: Aldege Cholette (aldege) on Jan 14, 2012

Still very nice Russell,but the Reds have a boring logo,lol. Russell,i'm not sure if you've noticed,but i don't usually rate your puzzles when i first see them. I tend to wait and see how others rate them first. This is because I tend to rate all puzzles high. I won't rate a puzzle below what i think is a 3 in quality,and i give every puzzle a 3 for difficulty. I don't solve puzzles usually so i give a 3 so that my rating will count,and if i think a puzzle isn't so great,i just won't rate it at all. I have rated all of your puzzles,and none below a 4 for quality. A few got 5's from me. I know and appreciate the effort it takes to make puzzles and i think yours have been top notch regardless of how big you have to make them to get the detail that you are getting. Don't get discouraged by the lack of comments from people.I would love to see you make some other puzzle subjects as well,either during or after you do all your MLB series. Keep up the good work and keep having fun buddy.:)

Aldege, thank you very much for your comments, I really have a lot of fun doing them and await your comments on each one after I publish it, I appreciate all the tips you have given me and the lack of comments from others doesn't bother me. I just like making them. I used to draw them freehand when I was a kid and put them up around my room, I always did football and baseball logo's. Not sure what to do next though. Again, thank you Aldege for all your comments. Oh yes, and by the way the Reds do have a boring logo, but their team was not boring back in the days of the "Big Red Machine".

Thx Russell,i love your spirit and attitude. When i was a kid i loved drawing freehand. I use to do goalies making great saves,or hot rods drag racing and popping wheelies. I still do freehand drawing. Last year i did a bunch of Christmas card drawings. It's fun,lol. Yeah the Reds have a great history.:)

Aldege, who died and made you rating god? LOL
I have even seen you comment multiple times about how ratings don't matter, and to focus on the comments, so why do you try and mess with things then, especially on other people's puzzles? I can sort of understand playing the Good Samaritan and trying to help bring people's quality ratings up so they don't feel bad, but the worst part is that you rate a 3 for difficulty on every puzzle. What is the point of that? You don't even solve puzzles! That could potentially lead people away from an easy solve if they are looking for one (by overrating with a 3), or lead people away from a challenging solve if they are looking for one (by underrating with a 3). Trust me, from personal experience, I know that Jan monitors this site, and he is ever vigilant of wayward ratings. Let him worry about the ratings. He knows what he is doing.

Anyway I like your logos, Russell, and I like a lot of your puzzles too, Aldege.

Adam,i by no way think i am the rating god. It was my understanding that my rating for quality without rating for difficulty would mean that my rating at all would not show up. Apparently i was wrong. Niki just explained the actual procedure to me. A 3 rating is just average,so i didn't feel like i was doing anything wrong. I doubt that many people would shy away from solving a puzzle that is rated average for difficulty,heck even i try some that are 3,and i truly suck at solving.Besides i rarely rate puzzles at all,i tend to only rate the ones that i think are truly worthy of a high rating and only after others have already rated them,or if i think someone has rated a great one way too low. Yes i don't care about the ratings of my own puzzles,cause people will tell me if they like it or not,and we all know i have a few people here that would rate mine low just cause they don't like me,but that doesn't mean i shouldn't give someone else a good rating that they truly deserve. Anyway,i'm glad you like a lot of my puzzles Adam,and you don't need to worry about my rating puzzles messing with people wanting to try to solve them,now that i understand that i can rate quality alone. Thx for your input Adam,now i have to go have a good cry cause my feelings are so hurt.lol:)

Comment Suppressed:Click below to view spoilers

lol Russell.:)

Show: Spoilers

Goto next topic

You must register and log in to be able to participate in this discussion.